Welcome to International Network for Natural Sciences | INNSpub

Review of some methods of calculating intercrop efficiencies with particular reference to the estimates of intercrop benefits in wheat/faba bean system

Review Paper | October 1, 2011

| Download 12

Ibrahim Yahuza

Key Words:

Int. J. Biosci.1( 5), 18-30, October 2011


IJB 2011 [Generate Certificate]


Intercropping (growing two or more crops together simultaneously) is increasing being adopted worldwide, probably because there have been suggestions that the system is beneficial in terms of land use efficiency compared to sole cropping. There are several indices for estimating intercrop performance compared to the component sole crops, but as reviewed in this paper, the land equivalent ratio (LER) is the most widely adopted. Yet the LER is constrained because it is not able to account for the relative duration each component in the intercrop spent in the field may have had on intercropping performance. Area time equivalency ratio (ATER) appears to have solved this problem well. However, neither ATER nor LER can account for the physiological or physical basis for the intercropping performance. The crop performance ratio (CPR) is more appropriate in this regard, even though CPR ‘adjusted for time’, (CPRT) is more efficient where the component crops differ in growth duration. In addition, particularly for intercrops with commercial value, there may be a need to compute a monetary advantage (MA) for intercropping. This paper concludes that in addition to the LER, for certain intercrops such as wheat/faba bean system that has not been widely adopted, there may be a need to use other indices such as ATER, CPR, CPRT and MA as may be applicable in order to understand more fully the nature of intercrop benefits that may exist. Indeed such type of information may help to attract potential growers.


Copyright © 2011
By Authors and International Network for
Natural Sciences (INNSPUB)
This article is published under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution Liscense 4.0

Review of some methods of calculating intercrop efficiencies with particular reference to the estimates of intercrop benefits in wheat/faba bean system

Abera T, Feyisa D. 2008. Faba bean and field pea seed proportion for intercropping system in Horro highlands of Western Ethiopia. African Crop Science Journal 16, 243-249.

Azam-Ali SN. 1995. Assessing the efficiency of radiation use by intercrops. Cited in Azam-Ali SN, Squire, GR. 2002. Principles of Tropical Agronomy. CABI, Wallingford, UK.

Azam-Ali SN, Squire GR. 2002. Principles of Tropical Agronomy. Wallingford, UK: CABI.

Azam-Ali SN, Mathews RB, Williams JH, Peacock JM. 1990. Light use, water uptake and performance of individual components of a sorghum/groundnut intercrop. Experimental Agriculture 26, 413-427.

Banik P, Midya A, Sarkar BK, Ghose SS. 2006. Wheat and chickpea intercropping system in an additive series experiment; advantages and weed smothering. European Journal of Agronomy 24, 325-332.

Baumann DT, Bastiaans L, Kropff MJ. 2001. Competition and crop performance in a leek-celery intercropping system. Crop Science 41, 764-774.

Bulson  HAJ,  Snaydon  RN,  Stopes  CE1997. Effects of plant density on intercropped wheat and field beans in an organic farming system. Journal of Agricultural Sciences 128, 59-71.

Confalone A, Lizaso JI, Ruiz-nogueira B, Lopez-cedron F, Sau F. 2010. Growth, PAR use efficiency, and yield components of field-grown Vicia faba L. under different temperature and photoperiod regimes. Field Crops Research 115, 140-148.

Dhima KV, Lithourgidis AS, Vasilakoglou IB, Dordas CA. 2007. Competition indices of common vetch and cereal intercrop in two seeding ratio. Field Crops Research 100, 249-256.

Dolman G. 1985. Density trials with systematic designs on intercropped carrots and onions. PhD Thesis, University of Reading, United Kingdom.

Francis CA. 1989. Biological efficiencies in multiple-cropping systems. Advances in Agronomy 42, 1-42.

Fukai S. 1993. Intercropping-bases of productivity. Field Crops Research 34, 239-245.

Fukai S, Trenbath BR. 1993. Processes determining intercrop productivity and yields of component crops. Field Crops Research 34, 247-271.

Ghanbari-Bonjar A, Lee HC. 2002. Intercropped field beans (Vicia faba) and wheat (Triticum aestivum) for whole crop forage: effect of nitrogen on forage yield and quality. Journal of Agricultural Science, 138, 311-315.

Ghaley BB, Hauggaard-Nielsen H, Hogh-Jensen H, Jensen ES. 2005. Intercropping of wheat and pea as influenced by nitrogen fertilization. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 73, 201-212.

Harris D, Natarajan M, Willey RW. 1987. Physiological basis for yield advantage in a sorghum/groundnut intercrop exposed to drought 1: dry matter production, yield and light interception. Field Crops Research 17, 259-272.

Hauggard-Nielsen H, Andersen MK, Jørnsgaard B, Jensen ES. 2006. Density and relative frequency effects on competitive interactions and resource use in pea-barley intercrops. Field Crops Research 95, 256-267.

Haymes R, Lee HC. 1999. Competition between autumn and spring planted grain intercrops of wheat (Triticum aestivum) and field bean (Vicia faba). Field crops Research 62,167-176.

Helenius J, Jokinen K. 1994. Yield advantage and competition in intercropped oats (Avena sativa L.) and faba bean (Vicia faba L.): application of the hyperbolic yield-density model. Field Crops Research 37, 85-94.

Hiebsch CK, McCollum RE. 1987. Area-X-time equivalency ratio; a method for evaluating the productivity of intercrops. Agronomy Journal 79, 15-22.

Hongo H. 1995. Light and water use in intercropping. PhD Thesis, University of Reading, United Kingdom.

Innis D. 1997. Intercropping and the scientific basis of traditional agriculture. London, UK: Intermediate Technology publication.

Li L, Yang S, Li X, Zhang F, Christie P. 1999. Interspecific complementary and competitive interactions between intercropped maize and faba bean. Plant and Soil 212, 105-114.

Mead R, Willey RW. 1980. The concept of a land equivalent ratio and advantages in yields from intercropping. Experimental Agriculture 16, 217-228.

McCance RA, Widdowson E. 1978. The composition of foods. Cited in Azam-Ali, SN, Squire, GR. 2002. Principles of Tropical Agronomy. Wallingford, UK: CABI.

Nix J. 2009. Farm management pocketbook 39th edition. Melton Mowbray, UK: Pocketbook.

Ofori F, Stern WR. 1987. Cereal-legume intercropping systems. Advances in Agronomy 41, 41-90.

Osiru DSO, Willey RW. 1972. Studies on mixtures of dwarf sorghum and beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) with particular reference to plant population. Journal of Agricultural Science 79, 531-540.

Oyejola BA. 1983. Some statistical considerations in the use of the land equivalent ratio to assess yield advantage in intercropping. PhD Thesis, University of Reading, United Kingdom.

Oyejola BA, Mead R. 1982. Statistical assessment of different ways of calculating land equivalent ratios (LER). Experimental Agriculture 18, 125-138.

Passmore R, Eastwood MA. 1986. (Eds.) Human Nutrition and Dietetics. Cited in Azam-Ali, SN, Squire,              GR., Principles of Tropical Agronomy. Wallingford, UK: CABI.

Patrick JW, Stoddard FL. 2010. Physiology of flowering and grain filling in faba bean. Field Crops Research 115, 234-242.

Rao MR, Willey RW. 1980. Evaluation of yield stability in intercropping studies on sorghum/pigeon pea. Experimental Agriculture 16, 105-116.

Sahile S, Fininsa C, Sakhuja PK, Ahmed S. 2008. Effect of mixed cropping and fungicides on chocolate spot (Botrytis fabae) of faba bean (Vicia faba) in Ethiopia. Crop Protection 27, 275-282.

Tosti G, Guiducci M. 2010. Durum wheat-faba bean temporary intercropping : effects on nitrogen supply and wheat quality. European Journal of Agronomy 33, 157-165.

Tsay JS, Fukai S, Wilson GL. 1988. Intercropping cassava with soyabean cultivars of varying maturities. Field Crops Research 19, 211-225.

Vandermeer J. 1989. The Ecology of intercropping. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University press.

Willey RW. 1979. Intercropping –Its importance and research needs. Part 1. Competition and yield advantages. Field Crop Abstracts 32, 1-10.

Willey RW. 1985. Evaluation and presentation of intercropping advantages Experimental Agriculture 21, 119-133.

Willey RW, Heath SB. 1969. The quantitative relationship between plant population and crop yield. Advances in Agronomy 21, 281-321.

Willey  RW,  Mohammed    N,  Morse  S.  1997. Factors affecting compensation in intercropping when one component fails. Tropical Agriculture 74, 313-316.

Wright AJ. 1981. The analysis of yield-density relationship in binary mixtures using inverse polynomials. Journal of Agricultural Science 96, 561-567.

Zhang L, van der Werf W, Zhang S, Li B, Spiertz JHJ. 2007. Growth, yield and quality of wheat and cotton in relay strip intercropping systems. Field Crops Research 103, 178-188.